July 6 people found the following review helpful.
Fantastic book, but there are some songs in my opinion
For YJM
As a collector of books of guitar tablature, more for its accuracy is limited to me reading the single tab, I decided to buy this book from the local Guitar Center tonight. The good news is that we will price match to Amazon, so you get the benefit of convenience stores retail at discount prices online. Make no mistake, this is an expensive book, and the discount from Amazon is important, so I was happy to Guitar Center will honor the price from Amazon. Even without the price to match the book is probably worth the price, it includes a lot of songs and the transcripts are very well done.
It should be the duty of every professional transcriber close study of the artist that is being transcribed. This way they can learn different techniques that may not have been obvious at first listen. Unfortunately, too often the transcribers did not go a step further, and the wind with books that are clearly not accurate, and certainly not representative of the techniques used by the artist. A couple of months ago I took the book of Steve Vai Real Illusions tab, and was disappointed to see the tab ridiculous trying to build the church. If you've ever seen Vai play live, you can see that uses unorthodox techniques to bring your left hand on the neck and striking with his right hand, like a keyboard. This is done by necessity, not for show, and there really is no other way to play the intro and solo. At least that's what I thought until I saw the Real Book of Illusions tab. Evidently the writer did not study the Vai style game, and so completely frustrated with the finger touching the areas of building the Church, instead of using a rare combo of hammer ons, pull-offs, large and chain breaks, it was a disaster to read through. Errors like to kill all the confidence the rest of the book is better. It would be better if the artists involved in the transcription process, but usually are not, it seems strange to me. Someone takes the time to transcribe my music I would do everything possible to ensure its accuracy.
Now, the transcription of Jimmy Page will not be as demanding as Steve Vai, but there are nuances that the novice writer is lost. For example, in the song No Quarter, states the following at the beginning of the song, "Sound recording half-tone lower than written. No Quarter was carried out in D minor and manipulating the tape speed produced a recording that sounds C # minor. "Brilliant, that's the kind of thing I want to see in a book of guitar transcription. This clearly means that the author did his homework on the artist, and therefore, my confidence in the accuracy of the songs is up. There are notes on other songs in the book when necessary. The tab itself is clear and easy to read, the logic suggested fingerings. I've seen a few books written in a style Zep tablature very strange, confusing and difficult to read, and I'm not sure why that is transcribed in this way. This book clearly has a different focus for the better.
The song selection is great, but I was disappointed there were some classics that are missing from the collection. The following are the songs that I would have liked to include: Celebration Day, Gallows Pole, who is the Way, The Rain Song, in the Light, Ten Years Gone, Fool In The Rain, and the solo acoustic guitar Bron -Yr-Aur have been fine too. Otherwise it is a stellar collection of songs, and is more or less what I expected a better time to book style. Any song written in a tune is labeled as such, and performance notes are also provided as mentioned in the previous paragraph. Chord charts are provided for parts that are repeated, as well as several graphics for the sections of the song where you use more than one guitar. Anyone who is a fan of Zep often layered Page knows his guitar parts, employing up to seven multi-guitar parts on some songs up.
If you're a fan of Zeppelin and is struggling to learn their songs on guitar, I can not recommend this book enough. It is very well done. My only criticism, as well as the omission of some songs, is that the book was not flat unless you are learning a song from the central section of the book. In fact, guitar book publishers need to get a handle on the major faux pau to be repeated in many of these books of guitar tablature. It's just a pain in the butt, and the solution of a folder of drawings is very easy, but rarely used. Otherwise the quality of the book is also high, and I do not think anyone will have problems with it falling apart after multiple uses. This is as good as it gets Led Zeppelin guitar tab books!